In this blog post I talk about the stories of both George R.R Martin’s A Song of Ice and Fire and Stephen King’s The Dark Tower series. This post contains no spoilers as such, but if you wish to enter these fictional worlds completely blind – that is, without so much as a hint to even the structure or reception of a story – I advise you avoid this blog post.
My private reading over the last two years have consisted firstly of A Song of Ice and Fire and then of The Dark Tower. (I am aware that this is a long reading time, but I enjoy taking it slow.) And whilst at the time I was fully immersed in George R.R Martin’s fantasy world, I found that Stephen King ultimately captivated me more with his substantially less popular series.
When I put down the final book of The Dark Tower at 2AM this morning, I did so with great satisfaction, and with that tingling emptiness which only the greatest of fictional journeys can leave you. And, along this particular journey I had to stop and marvel and how I did not feel this upon closing A Dance with Dragons. This is, of course, mostly due to the fact that A Song of Ice and Fire is still an incomplete series, but it’s something more than that. Something closer.
My theory is that it’s because of the scale. Whilst GRRM’s epic spans through many contextually separated character’s minds and across a vast landscape all at once, Stephen King’s centerpiece always stays in the same location, focusing mostly on the same characters. And due to this, I found myself able to understand and enjoy these characters to a far greater extent. For example, take my favourite character in A Song of Ice and Fire, Tyrion Lannister. His journey through the world (of ice and fire, hurr hurr) was of great interest to me during my reading, but it was constantly interrupted with the narrative shifting to other, albeit equally interesting characters. (Apart from Catelyn. Sorry Catelyn.) And whilst I understand this is how this particular story was chosen to be told, that it is the right decision for this particular story, I also can’t help but feel that I was travelling alongside Roland Deschain and his ka-tet whereas I was only observing the Starks.
This certainly isn’t a criticism of GRRM’s storytelling, but an evaluation of my choice of favourite between two options. It is also laced with confusion; from what I’ve read and seen, The Dark Tower is nowhere near Stephen King’s most famous works. Hell, I’d never heard of it until I saw it recommended and found it at a car boot. Perhaps this is just because I don’t – didn’t – follow King as closely as some other authors. But even King himself acknowledges in his final editor’s note that The Dark Tower hasn’t been the most successful of his works, even if it is what he may have put his hardest efforts into. I suppose it’s interesting to consider how differently our creations are viewed from the perspective of ourselves as opposed to that of the consumer’s; I’m sure the author’s favourite is often never that of the public’s.
Apologies for this largely unstructured and altogether pointless blog post. Having finished two large series of books, I felt the need to ramble a little concerning my thoughts on the two. After going on two journeys of such epic proportion, I’m after something a tad lighter now, something more easy-going and requiring less of a dedication to the characters within. I’ve already chosen and begun my next story, but it probably won’t get a blog post when I’m finished due to it being a collection of short novels. Unless I have something to say about collections of short novels, at least.